![Keep Us Strong](/static/gfx/ja-cg.jpg)
![WikiLeaks logo](/static/gfx/WL_Hour_Glass_small.png)
Currently released so far... 5420 / 251,287
Articles
Browse latest releases
2010/12/01
2010/12/02
2010/12/03
2010/12/04
2010/12/05
2010/12/06
2010/12/07
2010/12/08
2010/12/09
2010/12/10
2010/12/11
2010/12/12
2010/12/13
2010/12/14
2010/12/15
2010/12/16
2010/12/17
2010/12/18
2010/12/19
2010/12/20
2010/12/21
2010/12/22
2010/12/23
2010/12/24
2010/12/25
2010/12/26
2010/12/27
2010/12/28
2010/12/29
2010/12/30
2011/01/01
2011/01/02
2011/01/04
2011/01/05
2011/01/07
2011/01/09
2011/01/10
2011/01/11
2011/01/12
2011/01/13
2011/01/14
2011/01/15
2011/01/16
2011/01/17
2011/01/18
2011/01/19
2011/01/20
2011/01/21
2011/01/22
2011/01/23
2011/01/24
2011/01/25
2011/01/26
2011/01/27
2011/01/28
2011/01/29
2011/01/30
2011/01/31
2011/02/01
2011/02/02
2011/02/03
2011/02/04
2011/02/05
2011/02/06
2011/02/07
2011/02/08
2011/02/09
2011/02/10
2011/02/11
2011/02/12
2011/02/13
2011/02/14
2011/02/15
2011/02/16
2011/02/17
2011/02/18
2011/02/19
2011/02/20
2011/02/21
2011/02/22
2011/02/23
2011/02/24
2011/02/25
2011/02/26
2011/02/27
2011/02/28
Browse by creation date
Browse by origin
Embassy Athens
Embassy Asuncion
Embassy Astana
Embassy Asmara
Embassy Ashgabat
Embassy Ankara
Embassy Amman
Embassy Algiers
Embassy Addis Ababa
Embassy Accra
Embassy Abuja
Embassy Abu Dhabi
Embassy Abidjan
Consulate Amsterdam
American Institute Taiwan, Taipei
Embassy Bujumbura
Embassy Buenos Aires
Embassy Budapest
Embassy Bucharest
Embassy Brussels
Embassy Bridgetown
Embassy Bratislava
Embassy Brasilia
Embassy Bogota
Embassy Bishkek
Embassy Bern
Embassy Berlin
Embassy Belgrade
Embassy Beirut
Embassy Beijing
Embassy Banjul
Embassy Bangkok
Embassy Bandar Seri Begawan
Embassy Bamako
Embassy Baku
Embassy Baghdad
Consulate Barcelona
Embassy Copenhagen
Embassy Conakry
Embassy Colombo
Embassy Chisinau
Embassy Caracas
Embassy Canberra
Embassy Cairo
Consulate Curacao
Consulate Casablanca
Consulate Cape Town
Embassy Dushanbe
Embassy Dublin
Embassy Doha
Embassy Djibouti
Embassy Dhaka
Embassy Dar Es Salaam
Embassy Damascus
Embassy Dakar
Consulate Dubai
Embassy Kyiv
Embassy Kuwait
Embassy Kuala Lumpur
Embassy Kinshasa
Embassy Kigali
Embassy Khartoum
Embassy Kampala
Embassy Kabul
Embassy Luxembourg
Embassy Luanda
Embassy London
Embassy Ljubljana
Embassy Lisbon
Embassy Lima
Embassy Lilongwe
Embassy La Paz
Consulate Lagos
Mission USNATO
Embassy Muscat
Embassy Moscow
Embassy Montevideo
Embassy Monrovia
Embassy Minsk
Embassy Mexico
Embassy Mbabane
Embassy Maputo
Embassy Manama
Embassy Managua
Embassy Malabo
Embassy Madrid
Consulate Munich
Consulate Montreal
Consulate Monterrey
Consulate Milan
Embassy Pristina
Embassy Pretoria
Embassy Prague
Embassy Port Au Prince
Embassy Phnom Penh
Embassy Paris
Embassy Paramaribo
Embassy Panama
Consulate Peshawar
REO Basrah
Embassy Rome
Embassy Riyadh
Embassy Riga
Embassy Reykjavik
Embassy Rangoon
Embassy Rabat
Consulate Rio De Janeiro
Consulate Recife
Secretary of State
Embassy Stockholm
Embassy Sofia
Embassy Skopje
Embassy Singapore
Embassy Seoul
Embassy Sarajevo
Embassy Santo Domingo
Embassy Santiago
Embassy Sanaa
Embassy San Salvador
Embassy San Jose
Consulate Strasbourg
Consulate Shenyang
Consulate Shanghai
Consulate Sao Paulo
Embassy Tunis
Embassy Tripoli
Embassy Tokyo
Embassy The Hague
Embassy Tel Aviv
Embassy Tehran
Embassy Tegucigalpa
Embassy Tbilisi
Embassy Tashkent
Embassy Tallinn
USUN New York
USEU Brussels
US Mission Geneva
US Interests Section Havana
US Delegation, Secretary
UNVIE
Embassy Ulaanbaatar
Browse by tag
AF
AE
AJ
ASEC
AMGT
AR
AU
AG
AS
AM
AORC
AFIN
APER
ABUD
ATRN
AL
AEMR
ACOA
AO
AX
AMED
ADCO
AODE
AFFAIRS
AC
ASIG
ABLD
AA
AFU
ASUP
AROC
ATFN
AVERY
APCS
AER
ASECKFRDCVISKIRFPHUMSMIGEG
AEC
APECO
AGMT
CH
CASC
CA
CD
CV
CVIS
CMGT
CO
CI
CU
CBW
CLINTON
CE
CJAN
CIA
CG
CF
CN
CS
CAN
COUNTER
CDG
CIS
CM
CONDOLEEZZA
COE
CR
CY
CTM
COUNTRY
CLEARANCE
CPAS
CWC
CT
CKGR
CB
CACS
COM
CJUS
CARSON
CL
COUNTERTERRORISM
CACM
CDB
EPET
EINV
ECON
ENRG
EAID
ETRD
EG
ETTC
EFIN
EU
EAGR
ELAB
EIND
EUN
EAIR
ER
ECIN
ECPS
EFIS
EI
EINT
EZ
EMIN
ET
EC
ECONEFIN
ENVR
ES
ECA
ELN
EN
EFTA
EWWT
ELTN
EXTERNAL
EINVETC
ENIV
EINN
ENGR
EUR
ESA
ENERG
EK
ENGY
ETRO
ETRDEINVECINPGOVCS
ETRDEINVTINTCS
ESENV
ENVI
ELECTIONS
ECUN
EINVEFIN
ECIP
EINDETRD
EUC
EREL
IR
IZ
IS
IT
INTERPOL
IPR
IN
INRB
IAEA
IRAJ
INRA
INRO
IO
IC
ID
IIP
ITPHUM
IV
IWC
IQ
ICTY
ISRAELI
IRAQI
ICRC
ICAO
IMO
IF
ILC
IEFIN
INTELSAT
IL
IA
IBRD
IMF
INR
IRC
ITALY
ITALIAN
KCOR
KZ
KDEM
KN
KNNP
KPAL
KU
KWBG
KCRM
KE
KISL
KAWK
KSCA
KS
KSPR
KJUS
KFRD
KTIP
KPAO
KTFN
KIPR
KPKO
KNUC
KMDR
KGHG
KPLS
KOLY
KUNR
KDRG
KIRF
KIRC
KBIO
KHLS
KG
KACT
KGIC
KRAD
KCOM
KMCA
KV
KHDP
KVPR
KDEV
KWMN
KMPI
KFRDCVISCMGTCASCKOCIASECPHUMSMIGEG
KOMC
KTLA
KCFC
KTIA
KHIV
KPRP
KAWC
KCIP
KCFE
KOCI
KTDB
KMRS
KLIG
KBCT
KICC
KGIT
KSTC
KPAK
KNEI
KSEP
KPOA
KFLU
KNUP
KNNPMNUC
KO
KTER
KSUM
KHUM
KRFD
KBTR
KDDG
KWWMN
KFLO
KSAF
KBTS
KPRV
KNPP
KNAR
KWMM
KERG
KFIN
KFRDKIRFCVISCMGTKOCIASECPHUMSMIGEG
KTBT
KCRS
KRVC
KSTH
KREL
KNSD
KTEX
KPAI
KHSA
KR
KPWR
KWAC
KMIG
KSEC
KIFR
KDEMAF
KGCC
KPIN
MOPS
MARR
MASS
MTCRE
MX
MCAP
MO
MNUC
ML
MR
MZ
MPOS
MOPPS
MTCR
MAPP
MU
MY
MA
MG
MASC
MCC
MEPP
MK
MTRE
MP
MIL
MDC
MAR
MEPI
MRCRE
MI
MT
MQADHAFI
MD
MAPS
MUCN
MASSMNUC
MERCOSUR
MC
ODIP
OIIP
OREP
OVIP
OEXC
OPRC
OFDP
OPDC
OTRA
OSCE
OAS
OPIC
OECD
OPCW
OSCI
OIE
OIC
OTR
OVP
OFFICIALS
OSAC
PGOV
PINR
PREL
PTER
PK
PHUM
PE
PARM
PBIO
PINS
PREF
PSOE
PBTS
PL
PHSA
PKFK
PO
PGOF
PROP
PA
PARMS
PORG
PM
PMIL
PTERE
POL
PF
PALESTINIAN
PY
PGGV
PNR
POV
PAK
PAO
PFOR
PHALANAGE
PARTY
PRGOV
PNAT
PROV
PEL
PINF
PGOVE
POLINT
PRL
PRAM
PMAR
PGOVLO
PHUMBA
PHUS
PHUMPREL
PG
POLITICS
PEPR
PSI
PINT
PU
POLITICAL
PARTIES
PECON
POGOV
PINL
SCUL
SA
SY
SP
SNAR
SENV
SU
SW
SOCI
SL
SG
SMIG
SO
SF
SR
SN
SHUM
SZ
SYR
ST
SANC
SC
SAN
SIPRS
SK
SH
SI
SNARCS
STEINBERG
TX
TW
TU
TSPA
TH
TIP
TI
TS
TBIO
TRGY
TC
TR
TT
TERRORISM
TO
TFIN
TD
TSPL
TZ
TPHY
TK
TNGD
TINT
TRSY
TP
UK
UG
UP
UV
US
UN
UNSC
UNGA
USEU
USUN
UY
UZ
UNO
UNMIK
UNESCO
UE
UAE
UNEP
USTR
UNHCR
UNDP
UNHRC
USAID
UNCHS
UNAUS
UNCHC
Browse by classification
Community resources
courage is contagious
Viewing cable 09MOSCOW3144, RULE OF LAW LIPSTICK ON A POLITICAL PIG:
If you are new to these pages, please read an introduction on the structure of a cable as well as how to discuss them with others. See also the FAQs
Understanding cables
Every cable message consists of three parts:
- The top box shows each cables unique reference number, when and by whom it originally was sent, and what its initial classification was.
- The middle box contains the header information that is associated with the cable. It includes information about the receiver(s) as well as a general subject.
- The bottom box presents the body of the cable. The opening can contain a more specific subject, references to other cables (browse by origin to find them) or additional comment. This is followed by the main contents of the cable: a summary, a collection of specific topics and a comment section.
Discussing cables
If you find meaningful or important information in a cable, please link directly to its unique reference number. Linking to a specific paragraph in the body of a cable is also possible by copying the appropriate link (to be found at theparagraph symbol). Please mark messages for social networking services like Twitter with the hash tags #cablegate and a hash containing the reference ID e.g. #09MOSCOW3144.
Reference ID | Created | Released | Classification | Origin |
---|---|---|---|---|
09MOSCOW3144 | 2009-12-30 14:02 | 2010-12-26 21:09 | CONFIDENTIAL | Embassy Moscow |
VZCZCXYZ0003
RR RUEHWEB
DE RUEHMO #3144/01 3641427
ZNY CCCCC ZZH
R 301427Z DEC 09
FM AMEMBASSY MOSCOW
TO RUEHC/SECSTATE WASHDC 5829
INFO RUCNCIS/CIS COLLECTIVE
RUEHXD/MOSCOW POLITICAL COLLECTIVE
RHEHNSC/NSC WASHDC
C O N F I D E N T I A L MOSCOW 003144
SIPDIS
E.O. 12958: DECL: 12/29/2019
TAGS: PREL PGOV PHUM KDEM RS
SUBJECT: RULE OF LAW LIPSTICK ON A POLITICAL PIG:
KHODORKOVSKIY CASE PLODS ALONG
REF: A) MOSCOW 603 B) MOSCOW 1226
Classified By: Pol Minister Counselor Susan Elliott for reason 1.4 (d)
¶1. (C) Summary: The prosecution in the Khodorkovskiy/Lebedev
trial has finished reading its 188 volumes of evidence, and
has moved on to questioning witnesses. An observer for the
International Bar Association stated his belief that the
trial is being conducted fairly. Related events outside of
Russia continue to affect the case. A deposition in a U.S.
court by Price Waterhouse Coopers (PWC) may show that PWC
received GOR pressure to disavow its prior Yukos audits; the
Russian Supreme Court upheld an ECHR ruling that Lebedev's
initial arrest was illegal; and an arbitration court in the
Hague found Russia to be bound by the Energy Charter Treaty,
leaving it open to a large judgment against it and possible
seizure of GOR assets abroad by Yukos shareholders. Despite
the case's wide implications, it continues to be a cause
celebre only for foreigners and a minority of Russians. The
case also shows the great lengths that the GOR is willing to
go in order to place a "rule of law" gloss on a politically
motivated trial. End Summary.
Recent developments
-------------------
¶2. (C) The trial of former Yukos chief Mikhail Khodorkovskiy
and his associate Platon Lebedev continues in Moscow's
Khaminovsky court, having moved from the reading of the
prosecution's evidence -- which comprised 188 volumes and
lasted throughout the summer -- to questioning of the
prosecution's witnesses. Thus far the prosecution has called
31 of its 250 witnesses, meaning that the trial will probably
last until 2012. XXXXXXXXXXXX told us December 23 that he believes the trial is being
conducted fairly and that Judge Danilkin has been doing
everything in his power to make sure that the defense gets a
fair opportunity to present arguments and challenge the
prosecution's evidence.
¶3. (C) Among recent developments in the case, the defense has
been trying to introduce the testimony of a former Price
Waterhouse Coopers (PWC) auditor, who was deposed in
California in August by Khodorkovskiy lawyers. The
prosecution has objected to the introduction of the
deposition into the case, complaining that they had not
received sufficient notice; however, according to Teets, the
Russian Embassy did not inform the head investigator in
Russia until recently. The PWC deposition goes to the heart
of Yukos's guilt or innocence; as Yukos's auditor, it signed
off on Yukos's financial statements from 1994 to 2003, only
to disavow this prior approval in 2007. As XXXXXXXXXXXX noted, if
the audits were properly withdrawn, this will be a "black
mark" for the defense; if not, it could help the defense, but
would greatly tarnish PWC's international reputation. Teets
said that the content of the deposition had not yet been made
public, but speculated that the auditor had testified that
PWC had been pressured by the Russian government into
withdrawing its prior certifications of Yukos books and
records.
Lebedev ruling and other "international" issues
--------------------------------------------- --
¶4. (SBU) The Yukos battle continues simultaneously both on
domestic and the international fronts, with some concrete
effects on the case's proceedings in Moscow. On December 23,
the Russian Supreme Court ruled that the 2003 decision to
arrest and detain Lebedev was illegal, in keeping with a 2007
ruling by the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR). (Note:
The GOR often loses cases at the ECHR, and its common
practice is to pay the compensation required by the ECHR's
rulings while ignoring the substantive redress of the
systemic problem involved. This decision represents a rare
departure from this practice and signals a potentially
encouraging trend. End Note.) The Supreme Court's ruling
indicated only that the first two months of Lebedev's six
years (to date) of incarceration were illegal, and thus might
be considered only marginally relevant. However, the defense
might use this ruling to argue that the entire conviction was
tainted by the illegal detention and therefore should be
thrown out. Defense lawyers told Radio Free Europe that they
have not yet decided how to proceed, but called the ruling a
"victory," while expressing bewilderment at the Supreme
Court's two-year delay in ruling on the case.
¶5. (SBU) On December 23, Moscow's Basmanny Court issued an
arrest warrant in absentia for former Yukos treasurer Andrey
Leonovich, which Khodorkovskiy's lawyers called a ploy to
pressure witnesses, and which will likely further exacerbate
tensions with the UK (where Leonovich now resides) over the
issue of extraditions. This move follows a December 2 ruling
by an international arbitration tribunal in the Hague that
Russia is bound by the Energy Charter Treaty (ECT), thus
requiring the GOR to defend itself against claims from Yukos
shareholders for an estimated 100 billion USD in damages (ref
A). This sum would be the largest arbitration award ever,
representing 10 percent of Russia's GDP, and although
collecting the entire amount would be difficult, it could
allow shareholders to seize state assets outside of Russia.
The ECT ruling could affect, among others, companies such as
Royal Dutch Shell and BP who were forced to renegotiate
contracts on terms favorable to the GOR.
Russians apathetic, but skeptical towards GOR
---------------------------------------------
¶6. (SBU) Given such significant international implications to
the case, and given Khodorkovskiy's former stature, one might
expect a large amount of focus on the Yukos case inside
Russia. However, most Russians continue to pay scant
attention (ref B). According to a December poll by the
Levada Center encompassing 1,600 respondents in 127 cities
and villages, only a little more than one-third of Russians
are following the case (a May Levada poll showed the same
figure for people who were at all aware that the case
existed). The same poll, however, revealed a notable
divergence in public opinion from the "party line" maintained
by Prime Minister Vladimir Putin. In his December 3
televised question and answer session with the public, Putin
defended the legitimacy of Khodorkovskiy's incarceration and
accused Khodorkovskiy of also being a murderer. He also
claimed that all of the earnings from the sale of Yukos were
being funneled into the country's Housing and Utilities Fund.
The Levada poll, however, showed that 65 percent of
respondents did not believe Putin's claim about the Housing
Fund, and 50 percent believed that Putin should be summoned
as a witness in the case.
Khodorkovskiy starting to lose hope
-----------------------------------
¶7. (SBU) Khodorkovskiy and Lebedev have consistently
maintained an upbeat demeanor, frequently smiling and
laughing during the proceedings, and chatting buoyantly with
supporters. Over the course of his imprisonment,
Khodorkovskiy has written a series of philosophical articles
(printed in liberal papers such as Vedomosti) that have
amounted to shadow policy papers of the type that he might
write if he were one of the President's advisors. He had
also expressed faith that the Russian court system would
exhibit sufficient fairness and rule of law, and Judge
Danilkin sufficient independence, to acquit him. In recent
months Khodorkovskiy has made pessimistic statements that he
does not expect ever to be freed. By all accounts, in 2003
Khodorkovskiy did not believe he would actually be arrested.
His thinking here seems to following a similar trajectory,
from naive refusal to believe what is happening, to the
gradual sinking in of the reality of his situation.
Comment
-------
¶8. (C) The fact that legal procedures are apparently being
meticulously followed in a case whose motivation is clearly
political may appear paradoxical. It shows the effort that
the GOR is willing to expend in order to save face, in this
case by applying a superficial rule-of-law gloss to a cynical
system where political enemies are eliminated with impunity.
It is not lost on either elite or mainstream Russians that
the GOR has applied a double standard to the illegal
activities of 1990s oligarchs; if it were otherwise,
virtually every other oligarch would be on trial alongside
Khodorkovskiy and Lebedev. There is a widespread
understanding that Khodorkovskiy violated the tacit rules of
the game: if you keep out of politics, you can line your
pockets as much as you desire. Most Russians believe the
Khodorkovskiy trial is politically motivated; they simply do
not care that it is. Human rights activists in general have
an uphill battle in overcoming public apathy and cynicism,
but nowhere more so than in the Khodorkovskiy case. We will
continue to monitor the case as it unfolds.
Rubin